Pro Tips

Updates

Unlock Growth with Data: HR Metrics Your Small Business Actually Needs

Jun 30, 2025

Let’s be honest, running a small business can feel like juggling swords on a tightrope… blindfolded. Between wearing 12 hats and keeping your cash flow alive, the last thing you want is to guess your way through hiring, managing, and retaining a team.

The good news? You don’t have to. The secret to better people decisions isn’t magic, it’s metrics. And no, HR metrics aren’t just for big corporations with fancy software and entire HR departments. They're your business's backstage pass to building a happier, more productive team without breaking the bank.

Why Should You Care About HR Metrics?

Tracking HR data helps you:

  • Make smarter, non gut-based, decisions

  • Avoid wasting money on hiring the wrong people

  • Spot problems before they explode

Think of metrics like your business’s health tracker. Just like your smartwatch counts steps and tells you when you’ve been sitting too long, HR metrics help you spot trends and course-correct before your team starts falling apart.

1 - Hiring Metrics: How Fast & How Expensive?

Time-to-Hire

What it tells you: How long it takes from posting a job to getting an offer of acceptance and a new hire in the door.

Why it matters: If it’s taking forever, your dream candidates are likely getting scooped up elsewhere.

How to measure it:

Track milestones: posting date → application review → interviews → offer → start date.

Goal: Under 30 days.

Fix it with:

  • Write clear, targeted job descriptions

  • A standardized interview process

  • Pre-screening tools to weed out the “not a fit” folks faster. Email templates, questionnaires, even quick phone interviews.

Cost-per-Hire

What it tells you: How much you’re actually spending to bring someone new on board.
Spoiler alert: it’s often more than you think.

Calculate it: (Recruitment + onboarding + training costs) ÷ number of hires

Cut costs with:

  • Employee referral programs to reduce advertising costs

  • Social media posts instead of expensive ads

  • Audit your ATS platforms to ensure you're not paying for features you don’t use

2 - Retention & Engagement: The “Are We Okay?” Metrics

You hire a rockstar. Three months later, they ghost. What happened?

High turnover, especially within 90 days, is like a flashing neon sign saying “something’s broken.” On the flip side, solid retention means your people are happy and sticking around. That’s the goal.

Turnover Rate

What is it: Percentage of employees who leave during a specific time period.

How to calculate it:

(Number of departures ÷ average employee headcount) × 100.

Watch for: Voluntary exits over 10% and/or new hires leaving fast.

Fix it by:

  • Reworking onboarding (it matters a lot). 90% of employees decide whether to stay within the first six months of employment.

  • Offering genuine recognition

  • Listening during exit interviews and implementing stay interviews (read more on our last blog post titled “Your Secret Weapon Against Surprise Resignations: How to Keep Great Employees”)

Retention Rate

What it means: The percentage who stay.

How to calculate it: (Number of employees who stayed ÷ number of employees at the start of a time period) × 100

Above 90%? Nice job.
Below 80%? Time to investigate.

What to watch for: Retention gaps by department or manager (if one team has great retention and another doesn't, the issue may be local to leadership or workload, not company-wide.)

Boost it with:

  • Offer Clear Growth Paths: discuss career goals in regular one-on-ones, promote from within where possible, and provide training, upskilling, or cross-functional opportunities.

  • Even small changes in how you onboard, recognize, and/or support employees can make a big difference. If you retain just one more team member because of it, the cost savings often pay for the effort.

Absenteeism Rate

Frequent “sick days” or mysterious Monday disappearances? That’s a red flag.

How to Track it: Days missed ÷ total available workdays

Solutions:

  • Launch wellness programs

  • Flexible schedules

  • Cultivating a culture people actually like showing up for

Satisfaction & Engagement

Don’t assume your team is happy—ask them. A simple survey question like, “Would you recommend working here to a friend?” goes a long way.

If the answer is ‘no’...

  • Act on feedback + communicate solutions

  • Recognize wins publicly

  • Invest in mentorship or growth programs

3 - Productivity & Profit: Are We Getting a Return?

Your people are your biggest investment, so what are they bringing to the table?

Revenue Per Employee

What is it?: Total revenue ÷ full-time headcount

Use it to: Check if you're properly staffed and running efficiently

Best practices:

  • Compare benchmarks in your industry

  • Monitor quarterly and year-over-year changes

Profit Per Employee

What is it?: Net income ÷ total staff

Why it matters: Shows what your team is actually contributing after expenses

Quality of Hire

Fast hiring does not mean smart hiring. Track how new hires perform, stay, and fit in.

Tip: Review performance at 3 and 6 months. Not loving the trend? Rethink your hiring filters.

Time to Productivity

How long until a new team member stops asking “Where’s the coffee?” and starts crushing their goals?

Improve it by:

  • Clear role expectations

  • Structured onboarding

  • Buddy systems or peer coaching

4 - DEI & Workforce Planning: Build a Team That Reflects the World

Diversity, equity, and inclusion isn’t a buzzword, it’s good business. Diverse teams are more creative, more innovative, and (bonus) make more money.

DEI Metrics

Track by gender, race, age, etc. (anonymously and respectfully).

Use it to: See who’s represented (or not) at all levels.

Action steps:

  • Write inclusive job posts

  • Offer DEI training

  • Track promotion equity

Total Cost of Workforce (TCOW)

What it is: The full cost of having a team, not just salaries, but benefits, taxes, gear, etc.

Why track it: It’s probably your biggest business expense, so you better understand it. Breakdowns by department can reveal overstaffing or underinvestments.

Training ROI

Is that workshop worth it?

Why it matters:

Shows if training is delivering returns (higher sales or reduced errors).

Track: (Improvement in performance ÷ cost of training) × 100

Look for: Lower errors, better retention, boosted productivity

Steps to implement:

  • Define learning goals upfront (example: increase sales by X%)

  • Use control groups or pre/post assessments

How to Start: No Fancy Tools Required

Feeling overwhelmed? Start small. Pick 5–7 metrics that match your goals.

Start here:

  • Time-to-hire

  • Cost-per-hire

  • Turnover rate

  • Absenteeism

  • Satisfaction scores

  • Revenue per employee

Pro tips:

  • Use Google Sheets or free survey tools

  • Set monthly or quarterly check-ins

  • Share wins with your team—it builds trust and momentum

Final Takeaways

  • Numbers reveal what feelings can’t

  • Pick what matters now, don’t try to track everything at once

  • Don’t just collect data, use it

  • HR metrics = happier teams, better hires, and smarter scaling

Quick Start Checklist

✔️ Choose your core metrics
✔️ Set realistic targets
✔️ Track consistently
✔️ Review and adjust
✔️ Keep your team in the loop
✔️ Celebrate the wins!

With just a handful of numbers and some thoughtful action, you’ll be surprised how much smoother your hiring, management, and growth efforts become. Want help figuring out what to track or how to start?

Accurate Pay Systems is here to help—reach out today and let’s build your best team yet.

Contact Us Today

Contact Us

Follow Us

Designed by Pixel8

Contact Us Today

Contact Us

Follow Us

Designed by Pixel8